Read the story
In July 1733, a ship nobody in Savannah had asked for came up the river. The William and Sarah carried forty-two Jewish men and women from London, most of them Spanish and Portuguese Jews whose families had fled the Inquisition. James Oglethorpe had founded Georgia only months before, and he had no instructions from the colony's Trustees about settlers who weren't Christian. By most accounts, the Trustees wanted them gone.
But Savannah that summer had a bigger problem. Fever was tearing through the young colony, and its only doctor had reportedly died that spring.
One of the passengers was a physician named Samuel Nunes. Back in Portugal, the story goes, he had lived a double life, outwardly Catholic and secretly Jewish, and he had treated the king himself. Then the Inquisition came for his family, arresting them during a Passover service. They got out to London. Now, at the edge of the British empire, he went to work on the sick, and when his supply of cinchona bark ran out, he reportedly stripped bark from local oaks and dogwoods instead.
The deaths, it seems, dropped sharply. Oglethorpe later credited Nunes with saving many colonists from yellow fever, and that gratitude helped persuade him to let the Jewish settlers stay and to grant land to fourteen of them, despite London's objections.
By 1735 they had formed a congregation, Mickve Israel, the Hope of Israel. When Spanish troops landed on St. Simons Island in 1742, most of the Sephardi families fled, but the Sheftalls and the Minises held on, keeping services alive in Benjamin Sheftall's home. In 1820 the congregation built the first synagogue in Georgia.
In 1878 it consecrated the one that stands on Monterey Square today, a Gothic Revival sanctuary by New York architect Henry G. Harrison, laid out in the shape of a cross and crowned with a cupola. Inside is the Torah scroll that came over on that uninvited ship. On special occasions, it still comes out to be read.