Read the story
On May 16, 1777, two of Georgia's most powerful men faced each other at twelve paces outside Savannah, pistols raised. Within three days one of them was dead, and nearly two centuries later people were still arguing over where he lay.
Button Gwinnett came to Savannah from England in 1765 and opened a store that failed. He bought St. Catherines Island to become a planter. That failed too. He signed the Declaration of Independence, wrote the first draft of Georgia's first state constitution, and in 1777 became Georgia's president after Archibald Bulloch died.
His rival was Lachlan McIntosh, who commanded Georgia's Continental battalion, and the two became bitter enemies. McIntosh's brother George was arrested for treason under Gwinnett. Then Gwinnett ordered an invasion of British East Florida. It failed, and each man blamed the other. On May 1, McIntosh publicly called Gwinnett "a scoundrel and lying rascal." Gwinnett challenged him.
They met a few miles east of town, on land belonging to the deposed royal governor. Each man shot the other. McIntosh, hit in the leg, recovered. Gwinnett took a ball in the thigh and died on May 19. McIntosh was tried for his death and acquitted.
Gwinnett was buried in what is now Colonial Park Cemetery, but no one knows exactly where. In 1957 a retired school principal, Arthur J. Funk, found a broken stub of stone there, and an archaeologist dug up a skeleton beneath it. A Smithsonian examiner judged the bones most likely a woman's. A local commission declared the site Gwinnett's beyond a reasonable doubt. Augusta tried to claim the remains, and Savannah refused. For about five and a half years the bones sat in Funk's guest room, until a fifteen-foot marble monument rose over them in 1964.
Collectors know of only fifty-one examples of Gwinnett's signature. The man who made it is rarer still: one disputed skeleton, under a monument that may or may not be his.