Read the story
On March 25, 1740, construction began on a 500-acre tract about ten miles south of Savannah. The man paying for it had no fortune behind him. He had a voice.
George Whitefield was an evangelist who had first come to Georgia in 1738. On that trip he saw the Lutheran-founded institution at Ebenezer and decided the colony needed an orphan house. He named his Bethesda, the House of Mercy, and he paid for it the only way he knew: by preaching. Starting in 1740 he preached almost daily across the colonies, and when he sailed back to England in 1742, an estimated twenty to thirty thousand people came out to meet him.
Whitefield insisted on sole control of Bethesda, and trustees complained he would not show them the books. Benjamin Franklin, one of its earliest supporters, suggested moving it to Philadelphia. Whitefield refused.
But the House of Mercy was sinking into debt, and Whitefield found something to blame. Georgia had outlawed slavery in 1735. By 1747 he was pinning Bethesda's money troubles on the ban, and he and his friend James Habersham, a Bethesda teacher, helped bring slavery back; it was legal again in 1751. Whitefield wrote that with Black labor he would have had enough to support a great many orphans. Then he bought enslaved people to work at Bethesda and on his Providence Plantation.
When he died in 1770, he left it all to his English sponsor, Selina Hastings, Countess of Huntingdon: the orphanage, 4,000 acres, and 49 enslaved people. She could not run it from across the Atlantic, and Bethesda nearly closed. In 1773, fire destroyed the house.
Still, it kept going. Renamed the Bethesda Home for Boys in 1900 and Bethesda Academy in 2011, it calls itself the oldest child caring institution in the country. The mercy was real for the children. So was the price, paid by people who never chose to pay it.