Alice Riley, the Pail of Water, and the Legend of Wright Square

Two Irish servants, a murdered master, a baby born in jail, and Savannah's most persistent ghost story.

📍 Savannah, GA

True CrimeParanormalHistory

Listen to this story, narrated, in the TourPods app.

Your first 20 stories are free — no credit card required.

Download free

Key facts

  • Wright Square was laid out in 1733 as one of Savannah's first four squares and was originally named Percival Square, for John Percival, 1st Earl of Egmont.
  • In 1763 Percival Square was renamed for James Wright, the last royal governor of Georgia.
  • Alice Riley and Richard White were Irish indentured servants bound to a Savannah colonist named William Wise.
  • Savannah's recorder, Thomas Christie, wrote in December 1734 that White, at Riley's direction, pretended to comb Wise's hair and twisted his neckerchief until he was almost suffocated, and that Riley then plunged his face into a pail of water.
  • Riley's execution was postponed because she was pregnant.
  • In a letter of March 19, 1735, Christie reported that Riley had been hanged within six weeks of giving birth, pursuant to her sentence, and that the child had since died.
  • Jenkins wrote that "The woman was hanged yesterday, and denied the murder of Wise."
  • Riley is widely described as the first woman hanged in Georgia.

Read the story

Savannah's recorder, Thomas Christie, set it down plainly. One servant pretended to comb the old man's hair, then twisted his neckerchief tight. The other took hold of his head and plunged his face into a pail of water.

The dead man was William Wise, a colonist who, by local accounts, kept cattle on Hutchinson Island, across the river from the young town. The servants were Alice Riley and Richard White, both Irish, both indentured to him. Wise was already ailing in early 1734 when he was found dead.

Riley and White are said to have run for South Carolina. They were caught, brought back, and sentenced to hang. White escaped jail, and a settler named Edward Jenkins hunted him down. White begged for his life on the way back to town and went to the gallows insisting he was innocent.

Riley's hanging had to wait for a simple reason: she was pregnant. She gave birth to a son in custody. Then, as Christie reported in March 1735, she was hanged within six weeks of the birth, and the child had since died. Jenkins added one line that still unsettles: the woman was hanged, he wrote, and denied the murder of Wise. She is widely remembered as the first woman hanged in Georgia.

Here the record thins, and the legend thickens. Local tradition puts her gallows in Percival Square, the green you know today as Wright Square. Ghost tours say she never left. The story goes that a frantic young woman still drifts among the oaks after dark, searching for her baby, and some tellings claim Spanish moss refuses to grow on the tree where she died. Even careful chroniclers warn that much of what's printed about her is embroidery.

So take the ghost as you like. The letters are real: a sick master, two servants far from home, a pail of water, and a mother who never saw her son grow up.

There are more stories where this came from — near you.

TourPods narrates the hidden history, true crime, and local lore of wherever you're standing. Your first 20 stories are free.

Download TourPods free