Read the story
The first Heisman Trophy ever awarded spent part of its life holding a door open. Jay Berwanger, a halfback from Dubuque, Iowa, won it in 1935, back when it was simply the Downtown Athletic Club Trophy. He left it with his Aunt Gussie, who used it as a doorstop.
A University of Chicago player winning that prize was no fluke. It was the legacy of Amos Alonzo Stagg, a Yale All-American who had studied under William Rainey Harper at Yale Divinity School. Stagg arrived in 1892 and stayed forty-one seasons. Chicago was a founding member of the Big Ten, and his Maroons won seven conference titles between 1899 and 1924, going eleven and oh in 1905. He's credited with the huddle and with putting numbers on uniforms.
Then came Robert Maynard Hutchins, named president in 1929 at just thirty, the youngest in the country. Hutchins forced out the seventy-year-old Stagg as too old to coach. Stagg kept coaching in California for fourteen more seasons and lived to 102.
Berwanger's prize took John Heisman's name after Heisman died in 1936. Berwanger became the first player ever drafted into the NFL, but he and George Halas couldn't agree on salary, fifteen thousand dollars asked, thirteen thousand five hundred offered, so he went to work for a rubber company instead.
By 1939, the Maroons were losing to Michigan 85 to nothing. Hutchins saw football as a campus distraction, and on December 21, 1939, the university dropped it. In 1946 Chicago left the Big Ten. Old Stagg Field, where Chicago Pile-1 was built beneath the stands, came down in 1957.
The game crept back anyway: a club team in 1963, varsity in 1969, Division III in 1973.
And that doorstop? It sits today in the Ratner Athletics Center on Ellis Avenue, the first Heisman, at the school that walked away from football, and then quietly walked back.