The Chicago Widow Who Willed Her Fortune to a Lakeshore Seminary

The Chicago Widow Who Willed Her Fortune to a Lakeshore Seminary

How Eliza Garrett turned grief and a mayor's fortune into Garrett Biblical Institute, beside Northwestern.

📍 Evanston, IL

HistoryCultureLandmarks

Listen to this story, narrated, in the TourPods app.

Your first 20 stories are free — no credit card required.

Download free

Key facts

  • Eliza Clark was born on March 5, 1805, near Newburgh, New York.
  • Eliza Clark married Augustus Garrett in 1825 in Newburgh, New York.
  • The Garretts' daughter Imogene, born in 1830, died of cholera in New Orleans in 1833 and was buried on the banks of the Mississippi.
  • The couple also had sons named Charles (born 1834) and John.
  • After difficulties in New Orleans the Garretts separated for a short while, then reunited in Chicago in 1835.
  • Augustus Garrett worked in Chicago real estate as an auctioneer and land speculator.
  • Augustus Garrett served as Mayor of Chicago from 1843 to 1844 and again from 1845 to 1846.
  • Augustus Garrett died on November 30, 1848, in Chicago after a short, sudden illness.

Read the story

In December 1853, a Chicago widow named Eliza Garrett made out her will. She had already buried a daughter and a husband. What she wrote down would plant a seminary in Evanston, beside a university that had not yet held a single class.

Eliza Clark had married Augustus Garrett in Newburgh, New York, in 1825. In 1833, their young daughter Imogene died of cholera in New Orleans and was buried on the banks of the Mississippi. The couple separated for a time, then reunited in Chicago in 1835, where Augustus made his name auctioning and speculating in land, and twice served as the city's mayor in the 1840s.

In 1848, Augustus fell suddenly ill and died. Eliza inherited a large share of his fortune, along with the considerable debts he left behind.

Through her church on Clark Street, she had seen how little the region offered Methodist ministers in the way of education. Some Methodist leaders worried that too much schooling might dull a preacher's holiness. Her money settled the argument. Her will left a considerable inheritance to found a biblical institute. On December 26, 1853, a meeting in Chicago invited the minister John Dempster to organize it.

The Garrett Biblical Institute became the first Methodist seminary in the Midwest, founded by the same circle of Methodists who were building Northwestern. In November 1855, the university's first building, Old College, finally opened for classes.

Eliza Garrett did not get to see much more. She died later that same month, at fifty, and her funeral procession was remembered as one of the longest the city had seen.

Today the seminary is Garrett-Evangelical, still its own institution on Northwestern's campus, still carrying the name of the widow who decided her fortune should outlast her.

There are more stories where this came from — near you.

TourPods narrates the hidden history, true crime, and local lore of wherever you're standing. Your first 20 stories are free.

Download TourPods free