Read the story
On a humid afternoon in New York City, the heart of Little Italy hums with energy. Mulberry Street bustles with tourists and locals alike, weaving between bakeries, cafes, and, tucked between them, small shops displaying tubs of brightly colored Italian ices. Lemon yellow, cherry red, and pistachio green shimmer beneath the sunlight—a sight as iconic as the treat’s history.
Little Italy’s story begins with the waves of Italian immigrants who arrived at Ellis Island in the late 1800s. Among their few possessions, these newcomers carried treasured recipes from home. One of these was for granita, a Sicilian frozen dessert made by mixing mountain snow with sweetened fruit juice. It was a community ritual in the old country, a way to gather and cool off under the Mediterranean sun.
Without Sicilian mountains in Manhattan, those early immigrants improvised. As ice became available in the city, vendors began shaving blocks by hand, mixing in syrup and fruit. By the early 1900s, the first Italian ice stands appeared along Mulberry and Hester Streets. Bowls of icy sweetness became a summer staple, especially for children who might have only a nickel to spare.
One family stands out in this story: the Ferraras. Antonio Ferrara opened a bakery in 1892, and while Ferrara’s is best known for its cannoli, it helped set the stage for the Italian ice tradition in the neighborhood. The real boom for Italian ices came in the decades that followed, as shops like the legendary Lemon Ice King of Corona in Queens and Benfaremo’s (a family-run business since 1944) built on the foundation laid in Little Italy. Yet, it was the smaller, sometimes nameless stands in Lower Manhattan that kept the ritual alive for generations.
Early recipes were humble—lemon, sugar, water—but the flavor roster quickly expanded. Vendors experimented with cherry, chocolate, and watermelon. Each flavor reflected the creativity, and sometimes the rivalry, of the neighborhood. Families like the DePalmas and the Rinaldis became known for their secret blends, sometimes fiercely guarding the precise ratio of zest to sugar. The debates over who made the best Italian ice became a neighborhood sport, but one thing was unanimous: the treat was more than a dessert. It was a taste of home, a marker of summer, and a small luxury everyone could afford.
As Little Italy changed, so did the landscape for Italian ice. The neighborhood’s borders shrank, longtime businesses struggled against rising rents, and Chinatown’s expansion transformed the area. Still, Italian ice endured, precisely because it offered a link to the past and a moment of relief in the city’s relentless pace.
Today, you can step into family-run spots like Caffé Palermo—where owner John DeLucie keeps the tradition alive—or walk along Mulberry Street during the Feast of San Gennaro and find makeshift stands selling ices to festival-goers. Newer shops experiment with flavors like blood orange and coconut, and many now cater to vegan or allergy-friendly diets. But the essence remains: a simple, refreshing dessert, made to be savored.
In true New York fashion, opinions about Italian ice are strong. Some locals insist it’s best eaten with a tiny wooden spoon; others prefer to slurp it straight from the cup. And don’t call it “water ice”—unless you want a debate with someone from Philadelphia.
The magic of Italian ice in Little Italy isn’t just in the taste. It’s in the shared experience—neighbors, friends, and strangers cooling off together on stoops and sidewalks. It’s in the way a cup of lemon ice can bridge generations, connecting today’s visitors with the immigrants who built the neighborhood more than a century ago.
So, the next time you’re wandering Little Italy, let your nose and your curiosity guide you. Pause for a cup of Italian ice—lemon, cherry, pistachio, or whatever catches your eye. As you savor the frosty sweetness, you’re not just tasting dessert. You’re tasting a story—one that belongs to the families, the streets, and the enduring spirit of New York City.